Discover the Possibilities
403(b)(9) Church Retirement
Plan Solutions
Housing can be an important part of a minister's overall compensation and financial picture. When planning for retirement, ministers may need to consider how housing arrangements and housing-related benefits interact with their broader retirement strategy.
What Is a Housing Allowance? A minister's housing allowance, sometimes called a parsonage or rental allowance, is a portion of a minister's compensation that a church or qualified religious organization may designate in advance for the minister's housing expenses. For federal income-tax purposes, a properly designated housing allowance may generally be excluded from a qualifying minister's gross income, subject to specific limitations. The IRS generally limits the exclusion to the lowest of the amount officially designated, the amount actually used to provide a home, or the fair rental value of the home, including applicable furnishings and utilities. The designation is important. The IRS states that the employing church or organization must officially designate the housing allowance before the payment is made.
A housing allowance is not the same thing as a 403(b)(9) contribution or distribution. Rather, it is a separate component of a minister's compensation and tax situation that should be considered when developing a comprehensive retirement strategy.
Important: Housing allowance rules can be complex, and eligibility and tax treatment depend on the minister's circumstances.
Why Housing Matters in Retirement Planning. Housing can become one of the most significant pieces of a minister's retirement picture. For many ministers, the financial plan isn't simply about accumulating enough money in a 403(b)(9) retirement account. It also involves determining where they will live, how housing will be paid for, what their retirement income will look like, and how the loss or continuation of housing-related benefits could affect their budget. This becomes particularly important when a minister transitions from active ministry into retirement. During their working years, a minister may receive a housing allowance or live in a church-provided parsonage. Retirement may bring a significant change in that arrangement.
A comprehensive retirement plan should therefore consider: Current housing costs; Mortgage obligations; Property taxes and insurance; utilities and maintenance; the potential need to purchase or maintain a home; retirement income from a 403(b)(9); Social Security benefits. Other investment and retirement accounts. The potential loss or change of church-provided housing. The key question is not simply, "How much do I have in my 403(b)(9)?" It is: "Will my retirement income be sufficient to support the life—and housing—I expect to have in retirement?" Housing and Retirement Income. One of the biggest mistakes a minister can make is planning retirement income based solely on today's expenses. If a minister currently receives a housing allowance, that allowance may reduce the amount of taxable compensation during working years, subject to the applicable rules. But retirement planning requires looking ahead to determine what housing expenses will actually look like after leaving active ministry. For example, consider a minister who currently owns a home and has a mortgage. During working years, the minister may receive a designated housing allowance that helps cover qualified housing expenses. In retirement, however, the minister needs to determine: Will the mortgage still exist? Will property taxes and insurance continue? What will utilities and maintenance cost? Will the minister remain in the same home? Will a new home be needed? Will there be church-provided housing? What retirement income will be available to pay those expenses? The answers can materially affect the amount of retirement income the minister needs. This is where the 403(b)(9) becomes part of the larger retirement-income conversation. The account may be an important source of retirement assets, but the appropriate withdrawal strategy should be considered alongside Social Security, other investments, pensions, taxable accounts, and expected housing costs. Housing Considerations for Ministers Who Own a Home. Homeownership can provide an important source of stability in retirement, but it also creates ongoing expenses that need to be incorporated into a minister's retirement plan. For a minister who owns a home, retirement planning should consider the relationship between the housing allowance, actual housing expenses, the home's fair rental value, and the minister's broader income strategy. The IRS specifically provides that a qualifying minister who owns a home may generally exclude the lesser of the officially designated housing allowance, the amount actually used to provide a home, or the home's fair rental value, subject to the applicable rules. Homeowners should also consider: Will the mortgage be paid off before retirement, or will retirement income need to support the remaining payments? Property taxes and insurance: These expenses don't necessarily disappear when a mortgage is paid off. Maintenance and repairs: A retirement plan should account for ongoing maintenance as well as unexpected major expenses. Home equity: Home equity can be an important part of a household's overall balance sheet, but it isn't automatically retirement income. A strategy may eventually involve downsizing, selling, borrowing against the property, or simply continuing to live in the home. Future housing needs: The home that works well at age 60 may not be the home that works best at age 75 or 80. The goal is to make housing decisions as part of the retirement plan rather than separately from it. Housing Considerations for Ministers Entering Retirement. The transition into retirement can be particularly important for ministers because housing arrangements may change at the same time that employment income changes. A minister who has lived in a church-owned parsonage, for example, may need to obtain other housing after retirement. A minister who owns a home may instead need to determine whether that home remains affordable and appropriate throughout retirement. The IRS recognizes specific rules for certain retired ministers, including circumstances in which the rental value of a home furnished by a church as compensation for past services, or a portion of a pension designated as a rental allowance, may qualify for exclusion from gross income. The requirements are specific, however, and should be evaluated based on the individual's circumstances. That makes the transition into retirement an important planning opportunity.Before retiring, a minister should consider: Where will I live? How much will housing cost each month? Will I have a mortgage? What happens to my current housing arrangement when I leave the church? How much retirement income will I need? How will my 403(b)(9) fit into that income strategy? What other income sources will I have? These questions should ideally be answered before retirement, rather than after the transition has already occurred. How Housing Fits Into a 403(b)(9) Strategy. A 403(b)(9) retirement income account can be an important component of a minister's retirement strategy, but it should not be viewed in isolation. The IRS describes a 403(b)(9) retirement income account as an arrangement for employees of church-related organizations that is treated as an annuity contract under Section 403(b). The plan itself must be established and maintained under the applicable plan requirements. For a minister, the broader retirement strategy may need to coordinate:403(b)(9) assets; Social Security; other retirement accounts, taxable investments, pension income, if applicable; home equity; mortgage obligations; expected housing costs; other sources of retirement income. The important distinction is that the 403(b)(9) and the minister's housing allowance are related pieces of the overall financial plan, but they are not the same thing. A minister's housing allowance may receive special federal income-tax treatment when the applicable requirements are met, while distributions from a 403(b)(9) retirement account are governed by the rules applicable to the retirement plan and the nature of the distribution. That's why retirement planning for ministers should go beyond simply asking: "How much do I need in my 403(b)(9)?" Instead, the question becomes: "How can my 403(b)(9), Social Security, investments, housing situation, and other resources work together to support the retirement I want? That is where comprehensive retirement planning can add significant value. Planning Beyond the 403(b)(9). Your 403(b)(9) may be one of the most important retirement assets you have—but it is only one part of the picture.For ministers, retirement planning can involve questions about housing, Social Security, retirement income, investments, taxes, and the transition from active ministry to retirement. At the Lance Hocutt Financial Group, we help ministers and church employees look at these pieces together and develop a retirement strategy based on their individual circumstances and goals.
[Talk With Dr. Lance About Your Retirement Plan →]
This material is provided for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended to provide tax or legal advice. Federal tax rules regarding ministers, housing allowances, retirement plans, and Social Security can be complex and may change. Ministers should consult their qualified tax or legal professional regarding their individual circumstances.
Tax rules relating to ministerial housing allowances can be complex. Information on this page is for educational purposes and should not be considered tax or legal advice. Ministers should consult their qualified tax and legal professionals regarding their individual circumstances.
